Briefly, Harry Potter from an Objectivist

Comments

I really enjoyed the book as well, and was glad to read your interesting analysis. For the most part, I agree, except that JK did properly use the phrase "for the greater good". It's first used as a slogan to justify something dumbledore thinks is good, but later he decides that the "greater good" isnt worth violating the rights of non-wizards. So, I think JK did a pretty good job of putting that vicious slogan in its place.

oh, and its always nice to have some of my favorite things benefit from a bit of objectivist thought. thanks again
Sorry about the horrendous delay. I just wanted to state that you're right, "for the greater good" doesn't end up in a positive light. My point was that those popular misconceptions which would normally ruin the theme of the book turned out to actually be treated rationally by Rowling. I expounded on selfishness because I thought it the least obvious example.

Post a comment

Already a Vox member? Sign in